Tip News

February 22, 2019

Caribbean islanders to vote on whether to retain London-based court

Caribbean islanders to vote on whether to retain London-based court
'In this file photo, a vendor displays colorful clothing on a beach in St. John's, Antigua and Barbuda, where voters on November 6, 2018 will decide whether to keep a London-based body as their final appeals court or embrace one closer to home' - By: AFP/File Jewel SAMAD

Voters in two Caribbean countries long independent from Britain will wrestle with thorny issues of fairness and sovereignty on Tuesday as they go to the polls to decide whether to keep a London-based body as their final court of appeals or embrace a court much closer to home.

Although the sun set long ago on British rule across most of the region, many English-speaking islands retain the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council (JCPC), which traces its roots to the Middle Ages, as the final word in the administration of justice.

The upcoming constitutional referendums in Antigua and Barbuda and in Grenada will gauge public consensus on officially adopting the Trinidad-based Caribbean Court of Justice (CCJ) instead. They require a two-thirds majority to pass.

The island states are tiny, with combined population of perhaps 200,000, and are best-known for their sunny climes and sparkling beaches.

That said, the court issue has raised deeply felt questions not only of sovereignty but of the impartiality and accessibility of justice to islanders.

"For the first time our population will have a real say" on matters crucially affecting their future, said Andy Liburd, spokesman for a public education committee in Antigua and Barbuda.

Grenadians opposed the court change in a 2016 referendum. This is the first time Antiguans and Barbudans will vote on the matter.

The JCPC, comprising British Supreme Court judges and senior judges of other Commonwealth countries, adjudicates on all manner of cases -- currently hearing, for example, a claim for damages resulting from a traffic accident in Antigua and Barbuda.

The court has also decided on weightier matters, including ruling in 2002 that it was unconstitutional for tiny St. Lucia to use capital punishment as the mandatory sentence for murder.

- Issue of sovereignty -

While governments in both countries are campaigning strongly for the Caribbean court, islanders are divided.

Many see ditching the Privy Council as an important step toward breaking centuries-old colonial ties and achieving true independence from Britain.

Others fear judges from small Caribbean nations, where political divisions and family ties run deep, may lack impartiality.

The Caribbean court heard its first case in 2005. Several Caribbean Community (Caricom) countries have signified their intention to eventually adopt it as their final appellate court, but only Dominica, Guyana, Barbados and Belize have done so.

The court's president, Justice Adrian Saunders, recently said it was an "embarrassment" that so much of the region shunned the court.

He called it an "anomaly" that laws made in Caribbean parliaments were interpreted by "British judges, all of whom reside in Britain."

- Impartiality concerns -

The possibility of political interference in the Caribbean court concerns some residents.

"How can we trust the CCJ?" asked Antiguan voter Chad Kelsick. "What happens when we leave the Privy Council and the CCJ crumbles into corruption? We will be left with no justice."

But Grenada Prime Minister Keith Mitchell said the Caribbean court would be "above and beyond partisan political interests."

And Steadroy Benjamin, attorney general of Antigua and Barbuda, argued that adopting the Caribbean court would make justice more accessible.

"The cost of going to the Privy Council is prohibitive. In 37 years of independence, only a handful of cases from Antigua have gone there," he told AFP.

Because the Caribbean court travels from country to country, "more people will be able to access it," he said.

"It's an affront to our sovereignty that a foreign tribunal should be our final court of appeal."

The Judicial Committee of Privy Council, established in 1833 but with roots in Medieval times, was once the court of last resort for the entire British Empire.

Today, it is the highest court of appeal for several independent Commonwealth countries and British territories.

Short link: https://tipnews.com/u/NzE0MTg=

See also:

Related articles

Sports court to rule in Semenya case by March 26

Sports court to rule in Semenya case by March 26

The Court of Arbitration for Sport said Friday that it will deliver by March 26 a decision in the controversial case pitting South African double Olympic champion Caster Semenya against the IAAF. Semenya is challenging proposals by the International Associatio

India rape victims demand dignity at first public rally

India rape victims demand dignity at first public rally

Teju Bai walked for a month to join a rally in India's capital by thousands of sexual assault survivors who came together in public for the first time to demand justice.Bai's daughter-in-law was raped last year. The young woman has been shamed and remains a

Apps send intimate user data to Facebook: report

Apps send intimate user data to Facebook: report

A news report Friday said many smartphone apps were sending highly personal information such as menstrual cycles and body weight to Facebook, without notifying users.The Wall Street Journal report based on its own in-house tests showed that intimate data could

HELLO, PLEASE TAKE A MOMENT TO RATE THIS POST Caribbean islanders to vote on whether to retain London-based court

Sending comment Close