Tip News

March 20, 2019

Landmark Australian ruling could spark land compensation claims

Landmark Australian ruling could spark land compensation claims
'Legal experts say the native title ruling will have huge implications for indigenous peoples' - By: AFP/File William WEST

Australia's High Court on Wednesday ruled that Aboriginal owners stripped of land rights should be compensated for "spiritual harm," in a landmark ruling that could spark a slew of cases countrywide.

The court ruled that the Ngaliwurru and Nungali peoples in the Northern Territory were entitled to compensation for being disconnected from their lands by the government.

Portions of the land in the isolated northern town of Timber Creek were used by the state government to build infrastructure, impinging, the court said, on "native title" rights and interests.

The court upheld a ruling that the group was entitled to compensation not only for the value of the land and lost interest, but "compensation for cultural loss".

The government had claimed the award for cultural loss was "manifestly excessive".

Awarding Aus$1.3 million ($920,000) for "cultural loss" the court said it assessed the groups' "spiritual relationship" with the land and "spiritual hurt" by the disconnection.

The court indicated that the assessment of compensation could vary according to the identity of the native title holders and their connection with the land or waters.

In advance of the ruling, legal experts at the University of Queensland said it would have "huge implications" for indigenous peoples.

"For Queensland and Western Australia in particular, the outcome will likely provide clarity on the significant amounts of compensation they may be liable for in the future," they wrote.

Both states are rich in resources and a vast amount of land could be affected.

Government officials have reportedly put the cost of potential compensation claims at more than Aus$1 billion.

The case "will have strong implications for the more than 2.8 million square kilometres of native title land holdings across the rest of Australia," said Tony Denholder, a partner at law firm Ashurst.

It "will likely to trigger compensation applications from many of the hundreds of native title holder groups around Australia, who finally have clarity – albeit limited – on how they might quantify the compensation owed to them."

"It is likely that nationally, the liability for native title compensation will run into the billions of dollars."

But according to Denholder there would be more legal complexities ahead and more case law would be needed to give a clear picture of how compensation will be assessed for mining projects, pastoral leases and agricultural development.

Short link: https://tipnews.com/u/ODY2MjE=

See also:

Related articles

Italy seizes blocked NGO migrant ship

Italy seizes blocked NGO migrant ship

Italy seized control Tuesday of an NGO ship it had prevented from landing nearly 50 migrants picked up off the Libyan coast, the interior ministry said.The authorities "are in the process of taking control of the Mare Jonio, escorting the boat into the (south

Nicaragua opposition refuses to resume government talks

Nicaragua opposition refuses to resume government talks

Nicaragua's opposition alliance said Tuesday that talks with President Daniel Ortega's government cannot resume until "political prisoners" are released and the repression of anti-regime protesters ends."There aren't the conditions to continue negotiatin

Musicians brace for Brexit disharmony

Musicians brace for Brexit disharmony

As the Brexit saga reaches a crescendo, classical musicians based in Britain fear that a disorderly divorce could threaten their European livelihood and stunt the development of potential maestros.Viola player Aliye Cornish told AFP she was particularly concer

HRW urges Japan to change transgender 'sterilisation' law

HRW urges Japan to change transgender 'sterilisation' law

Japan should "urgently" revise a law that effectively requires transgender people to be surgically sterilised if they want legal recognition of their gender identity, Human Rights Watch said Wednesday.Under rules introduced in 2004, transgender people who wi



HELLO, PLEASE TAKE A MOMENT TO RATE THIS POST Landmark Australian ruling could spark land compensation claims

Sending comment Close